Shiekh District SMS Feedback roll out, 12/07/2012, a set on Flickr.
Piloting Accountability Systems for Humanitarian Aid in Somalia using SMS Feedback from beneficiaries and integrating the feedback into Social Media.
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
Thursday, July 12, 2012
Ainabo District Beneficiary SMS Feedback roll out: June 21/06/2012
The
Beneficiary SMS Feedback roll out to Ainabo district took place on 18th June,
2012. We visited Ainabo town and 2 villages, Wadamogoo and Higladda villages.
The Community-Driven Recovery and Development (CDRD) has projects currently
implemented, including: construction of community centre, rehabilitating water
tanks and supporting agricultural activities.
Objectives:
1. Roll out Beneficiary SMS
Feedback system to Ainabo district.
2. Mobilize beneficiaries,
informing and explaining to them how the SMS feedback works.
3. Establishing good
working relations with the Community Project Implementation Unit (CPIU),
Village Committees and local DRC staff team leaders to help us implement the
project effectively and act as our contact point in the field.
We set off early on the 17th June
on a 7-hour roadtrip from Hargeisa to Ainabo district, covering 472km distance
and arrived in Ainabo at 4:20pm. During this rainy season the country
transforms into green and lush open space making the road trip very pleasant.
The second day of trip we visited two
villages, Higladda, 52km, and Wadamagoo, 15km from Ainabo respectively.
In Higladda village, we met the Community Project Implementation Unit (CPIU),
who welcomed us warmly and gave detailed information about the projects implemented
in their village by the CDRD. We, intern, explained how the beneficiary SMS
feedback system works, gave them posters with feedback number and brief
explanation and copies of FAQ on SMS feedback. We have also shared with the
beneficiaries our experience so far working with other DRC beneficiaries,
issues that have come up, such as receiving too many ‘requests’ for more
assistance that are outside our mandate and how we have developed the system to
cut waiting time for feedback and are currently able to send feedbacks within a
week maximum. The community members present expressed a delight at the
possibility of having a direct access to DRC and promised to send their
feedback. “This is the best form of communication for us as it is flexible and
we given a direct access to the DRC. This creates a big difference between the
DRC and other NGOs working in the district.” said one of the Higladda CPIU
member.
The Second village we visited was
Wadamagoo, located 15km east of Ainabo. It was just after the rains so
the village was very green and pleasant. We met some of the beneficiaries and
CPIU members. We explained and informally (as we do will all the beneficiaries
we meet) discussed about the beneficiary SMS feedback project. The
beneficiaries in this village asked more questions about the feedback system
compared to the beneficiaries in the our previous two visists. They seemed more
attentive and interested. Some of the beneficiaries tested the system while we
were with them to see if it works and if they would receive an automated
response as explained. There were also more youth and literate beneficiaries
present, which is no common in our field visits with beneficiaries.
The afternoon on the same day we also met
one of the Ainabo city beneficiary groups. Although Ainabo has three CDRD
projects running, we only had time to meet one project beneficiary group. We
planned to meet the other two groups the next day. We repeated the same
information and question and answer session and distributed posters with the feedback
number.
A violent incident and a sad loss
On the third day of our trip,
unfortunately, we received tragic news after one of the DRC rental car drivers,
Mohamed Said Maaweel, was ambushed and killed by militia in the disputed area
of Sanaag, and his vehicle taken. This took place just outside Ainabo district
late in the afternoon when he was travelling to qoridhere village, where the
CDRD is implementing a project. Mohamed was buried the next day and all DRC
staff were advised to leave Ainabo and return to Hargeisa until the security
situation was back to normal. This was a big shock to all staff and
particularly to Ainabo office staff as he has worked with them and they got to
know Mohamed as a kind and friendly young man. On the following day all DRC
operations in Ainabo district were temporarily suspended and we all left for
Hargeisa.
Due to this incident, our plan to roll out
the beneficiary SMS feedback to all the 15 villages in Ainabo district was
disrupted and we had to cancel until further notice.
We are very sad to have lost Mohamed and will remember him as very
helpful, kind and cheerful person.
Challenges
- Unpredictable
and volatile environment
- Intense
clan conflict which led to a bad community relations and mistrust between
some beneficiaries and local DRC staff
- Very
remote and not easily accessible
- Poor
network coverage
- Power
shortage to charge phones
Shortly after we returned to Hargeisa we received a
complaint from a beneficiary in this district. It was a serious allegation
implicating a staff member. We have followed our complaint procedure and
investigated the complaint to ensure it is genuine. It turned out to be a
personal grudge against a DRC staff member based in the Ainabo district. The
complaint and steps taken are also posted on our blog and Facebook page under the
title “The first not-so-genuine complaint”.
Monday, July 9, 2012
The first not-so-genuine complaint we have received!
Translated SMS: We are complaining about a persistent
corruption taking place in Ainabo DRC office, which you are responsible for.
The latest case involves the distribution of food for work and IDP, the staff
in Ainabo have fiddled with the number of beneficiaries. it was 1-390 person
and 150 persons, they divided as (....)!
From Ainabo Community
CDRD Project
Ainabo District
Original SMS: ku xafiska DRC ee cabashooyinka: Soo gudbin cabasho musuq maasuq oo soo noqnoqotay taas oo ka dhacday xafiiska DRC ee Caynabo.ayna udanbaysay dadka hadeer qoraal qaybintodo ka socoto caynabo ee ah, shaqo/raashinle iyo barokacayal tiradodu ahayd, 1-390.qof & 150.qof barakace waxayna uqaybisay si (.....)!
Ka timid Bulshadda
Caynabo
Follow up:
Step 1: To ensure this is a genuine complaint from a DRC beneficiary, first we called the complainant 5 time and he did not answer. We then sent him an SMS requesting more details and informing him that we are trying to reach him and to please answer the phone.
Step 2: The SMS was forwarded to DRC complaint team to carry out a further investigation and to ensure the authenticity of the complaint.
The respond of the complaint team: "We have called the complainant several times from different phones using the number provided and he switched off his phone. We think this is not a genuine complaint but a person who has a grudge against a DRC staff in Ainabo office".
Step 3: We sent an SMS to the complainant informing him that unless he provides more information to support his case and answers his phone, we can't address his complaint.
From Ainabo Community
CDRD Project
Ainabo District
Original SMS: ku xafiska DRC ee cabashooyinka: Soo gudbin cabasho musuq maasuq oo soo noqnoqotay taas oo ka dhacday xafiiska DRC ee Caynabo.ayna udanbaysay dadka hadeer qoraal qaybintodo ka socoto caynabo ee ah, shaqo/raashinle iyo barokacayal tiradodu ahayd, 1-390.qof & 150.qof barakace waxayna uqaybisay si (.....)!
Ka timid Bulshadda
Caynabo
Follow up:
Step 1: To ensure this is a genuine complaint from a DRC beneficiary, first we called the complainant 5 time and he did not answer. We then sent him an SMS requesting more details and informing him that we are trying to reach him and to please answer the phone.
Step 2: The SMS was forwarded to DRC complaint team to carry out a further investigation and to ensure the authenticity of the complaint.
The respond of the complaint team: "We have called the complainant several times from different phones using the number provided and he switched off his phone. We think this is not a genuine complaint but a person who has a grudge against a DRC staff in Ainabo office".
Step 3: We sent an SMS to the complainant informing him that unless he provides more information to support his case and answers his phone, we can't address his complaint.
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
A poem feedback sent by SMS!
Listen to the poem I'm shouting out which is about a real thing.
I'm someone who has
nothing to lose,
there is no land and
no food.
It was a dangerous,
hot drought, with all joy gone.
The DRC came to us
when we were crying for attention.
Female and male were
fed,
all of them, Ali.
If I look everywhere
at everything that happened and what the DRC did,
they have left a
legacy.
They will meet
Somalis' needs.
Dhawaaq gabay
dhegeystow hadaan dhab uga sheekeeyo,
nin dhagaagay baan
ahay,
dhulkiyo dheefta
taalaba
Abaar dhahartay
dhiinjara, markay dhaqasho noo dÃidey
Waxa qaylo dhalaan
noogu yimi- Danishka Yurub
Dhadig iyo labood waa
dhergeen dhaaxba caliyow
Hadaan dheehday
hagaago dhamaan aan dhinac kasta u eegay DRC dhabtii waxay qabteen dhaxal gal
weeyaani
Somalida waxa ka
dhiman bay dheellitirayaani.
Male beneficiary
El-Afweyn District
Male beneficiary
El-Afweyn District
Wednesday, June 13, 2012
SMS feedback highlights – Part 1: Complaint
Translated SMS: “My cash collection ID card was taken by force by
one of your staff in the Mogadishu office when I went to collect my payments. I
want to know why he took my card and would like your help in getting it
back. The staff who took my card accused me of having a duplicate
card, which is untrue.”
From male beneficiary,
Cash Relief project, Bondhere, Mogadishu
Follow-up:
Step 1: Complaint sent to the Mogadish Cash Relief team
to investigate and send us a response.
Step 2: Mogadishu team sent this response – This man
has 2 ID cards for one family, because his late wife and him have applied as 2
separate families. His wife has recently passed away and he has been collecting
her cash as he is her next of kin, as written in our database. He has came to
the bank with his ID card to receive the payment, and DRC team at the bank have
realized he is collecting 2 payments for the same family, and have reported to
me (Zaima, DRC Cash project manager). We talked to the bank telling them
not to pay this ID card. After investigation we raised his case with the area
manager and agreed to take away his late wife’s card. He is among 14 other
beneficiaries who have now been stripped of their duplicate ID cards.
He has contacted DRC
Cash Project Manager by telephone and she has explained the cash policy that
each household is entitled only to 1 ID card for cash collection. The
beneficiary did not accept the policy and DRC’s decision. The project
manager asked him to come to the office to discuss face to face, he did not
show up. He called her 2 days ago, sounding angry and threatening her to make
“trouble” for the DRC if his late wife’ ID card is not returned to him. This
was reported to Mogadishu Area Manager.
Step 3: We have spoken to the beneficiary relaying the
above message from the project manager. He has confirmed the duplicate ID card
indeed belonged to his late wife. He, however, tried to explain that his late
wife's mother and her siblings were the beneficiaries of his wife's cash and he
is now in a difficult position to support 2 families. The feedback team has
again communicated to him the DRC cash policy, each household is entitled only
to 1 card and there is nothing else we can do to help him. Beneficiary is
notified of the complaint closure as the Mogadishu team has followed procedure
and thus he has no case. We have offered one last solution for him to meet the
cash team in Mogadishu and talk things thorough calmly so they maintain good
working relations.
Tuesday, June 5, 2012
We receive polar opposite feedback sometimes, here is one example.
Translated SMS: We have nothing but praise and respect for the DRC
for the work it has done in our village, Aden Abokor.
Female beneficiary
Aden Abokor village
Salahley District
Translated SMS: Your humanitarian work is not good and efficient
in our village in Qol-Caday. You have not developed much in the 2 years you
were here and your projects are coming to an end.
Male beneficiary
Qol-Caday village
Salahley District
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)